Rooms didn't matter - ours was plenty large enough - balcony was just a lean over type but we had top floor island view that was great (just don't book the inside facing rooms as that is just weird!). Also much closer for your boat as it is right in the lobby vs walking the breakwater. We found the buffet at Captains Corner was awful (probably a hot outside thing), and it was much more suitable on Marina side with Aquarius (air conditioned) and one of the best steak houses on the island right there with LG Smith. Food options are also much better on that side.
The infinity pool/Blue Bar was a way better hang out than the Ocean Suites pool.way more comfortable. I'd stick with Marina side personally without kids.
